Darn it! Time to make do. I found a random piece of chipboard and cut out a star shape, mimicking the style of the ones I wanted to match. The color was different, so I painted all three pieces "Country Twill"- a color that looks like raw chipboard. I inked the edges and added the stars.
My star isn't exactly the same as the BasicGrey two, but it's close enough. Can you guess which one I made?
From Flamingo Scraps: Moxxie patterned paper, BasicGrey chipboard stars
Other: We R Memory Keepers patterned paper, Bazzill cardstock, EK Success punch, Folk Art paint, Reminisce stickers
Inspired by: Shannon Zickel, scrapbooks etc. August 2011
Mine is the large one. I'm happy with it. Pretty good for making do.